ACIC Earnings Preview: Options Price a ±9.2% Move
· The NYC Memo · ACIC reports 2026-11-04
American Coastal Insurance Corp reports November 4, 2026. The February 19, 2027 straddle implies ±9.16% against a 4.75% average reaction, with dealers long gamma and max pain at $9.
American Coastal Insurance Corp reports on November 4, 2026, with ACIC spot at $10.92. Shares sit -16.4% from their 52-week high after gaining +18.1% over the past month. For the February 19, 2027 expiry, the $1.00 straddle implies a 9.16% move, spanning $9.92 to $11.92 with implied volatility at 47.2%. The options market asks for an outsized move. Across 8 prints counted, the average realised reaction is 4.75%, closing higher 1 time and lower 7 times.
Dealer positioning shows a lean of long gamma, max pain at $9, and put to call open interest at 0.00. This dealer inventory structure will buffer volatility and anchor the tape into the print.
What the market will be watching
The market enters the American Coastal Insurance report focused on commercial residential policy retention and premium growth across core coastal markets. Options desks will evaluate underwriting margin pressure driven by catastrophe losses, storm exposure, and elevated reinsurance ceding costs. Traders will also watch litigated claim volume and reserve adequacy following state regulatory changes. Full-year outlook adjustments and reinsurance commentary will dictate whether post-earnings volatility leads to sustained positioning shifts.
What the options market is pricing
| Measure | Level |
|---|---|
| November 4, 2026 | |
| Expiry used | February 19, 2027 (109 days out) |
| Spot | $10.92 |
| ATM straddle | $1.00 |
| Implied move | ±9.16% ($9.92 to $11.92) |
| ATM implied vol | 47.2% |
| Put/call open interest | 0.00 |
| Max pain | $9 |
| Net dealer gamma | +$0.08mn per 1% move, LONG GAMMA |
| Heaviest call strike above spot | $15 (93 contracts) |
| Heaviest put strike below spot | $9 (2 contracts) |
Dealers sit long gamma into the print, which means their hedging leans against the move and tends to compress ACIC between catalysts. That damping disappears the moment the number crosses the tape.
How the stock has reacted before
| Report | Next-day move |
|---|---|
| Q3 2026, Oct 29 | -0.09% |
| Q2 2026, Aug 5 | -6.12% |
| Q1 2026, May 5 | -12.05% |
| Q4 2025, Feb 19 | -2.16% |
| Q3 2025, Nov 5 | -1.69% |
| Q2 2025, Aug 6 | +5.21% |
| Q1 2025, May 8 | -6.38% |
| Q4 2024, Feb 27 | -4.33% |
Across the last 8 prints the average absolute reaction is 4.75%, with 1 higher and 7 lower. The best was +5.21% and the worst -12.05%. Options are asking ±9.16%, which is 4.41 points richer than the realised average, the premium seller's case.
Where the stock is trading
| Measure | Level |
|---|---|
| Spot | $10.92 |
| 52-week range | $9.01 to $13.06 |
| Position in that range | 47% |
| From the 52-week high | -16.4% |
| From the 52-week low | +21.2% |
| Past week | -1.4% |
| Past month | +18.1% |
| Past three months | -0.1% |
| 50-day average | $9.82 |
| 200-day average | $10.68 |
How the options market is pricing it
The February 19, 2027 straddle marks $9.92 to $11.92 as the range the options market is paying for into the print, with ATM implied vol at 47% set to drain the morning after. A reaction inside that band hands the edge to premium sellers; a break outside it rewards premium buyers. Historically ACIC has moved 4.75% on earnings against the ±9.16% now implied, so the market is pricing this print richer than the recent average. Which side of that trade is right depends on the number, the guidance and where positioning unwinds.
Read the mechanics behind the crush in our earnings volatility guide, and pull the live memo for ACIC before the print.
Data as of November 2, 2026 from the live option chain, exchange price history and SEC-dated earnings reactions. This is research, not investment advice.
Related: ACIC options memo